the β3-structure (tetrahexahedron)

[ β0-structure | β1-structure | β2-structure | β3-structure | β4-structure | β5-structure | β6-structure | β7-structure | βn-structure ] – β-structures

NOT.PellissiersTetraicosahedron The oppositional β3-structure is the logical tetrahexahedron of Sauriol (1968), rediscovered independently (at a time in which Sauriol’s works war ignored by them) by Pellissier (2008) and Smessaert (2009). This βn-structure is very interesting since, differently from the previous ones (i.e. the β0-, the β1- and the β2-structure – at least as long as we currently know) it can be generated by several different γ-structures (that is, by several γ-structures which are not mutually isomorphic). This means that the β3-structure makes it possible (along with Pellissier’s intuition of this) to put into “oppositional equivalence” structures which otherwise seem utterly different the one from the other.

NOTA BENE 1: as it seems, Lewis Carroll was quite close to discovering this structure, although he seemed to have a huge obstacle in front of him: the absence of any kind of knowledge of the structure of the logical hexagon. This can be seen in some works of him, published posthumous, on “logical charts” (cf. Moretti, A., “Was Lewis Carroll an Amazing Oppositional Geometer?”, 2014).

NOTA BENE 2: In Smessaert and Demey’s “logical geometry” this structure, expressed differently (i.e. by highlighting other relations instead of the implication arrows, is called “rhombic dodecahedron”. As such, in some sense it had been partly discovered by Zellweger.

Instances of β3-structures generated by different (in shape) γ-structures:

  • the β3-structure of S5
  • the β3-structure of the binary connectives

This yields oppositional equivalences among apparently different γ-structures

  • Luzeaux D., Sallantin J. and Dartnell C., « Logical Extensions of Aristotle’s Square », Logica Universalis, 2, 1, 2008
  • Moretti, A., The Geometry of Logical Opposition, PhD Thesis, Université de Neuchâtel, Switzerland, 2009
  • Moretti, A., « Was Lewis Carroll an Amazing Oppositional Geometer? », History and Philosophy of Logic, 35, 4, 2014
  • Pellissier, R., « ‘Setting’ n-opposition », (pre-final draft), Logica Universalis, 2, 2, 2008
  • Sauriol, P., « Remarques sur la Théorie de l’hexagone logique de Blanché », Dialogue, 7, 1968.
  • Sauriol, P., « La structure tétrahexaédrique du système complet des propositions catégoriques », Dialogue, 15, 1976.
  • Smessaert, H., « On the 3D visualisation of logical relations », Logica Universalis, 3, 2, 2009

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s